Organizations succeed with threat modeling by starting small, aligning with developer workflows, automating for scale, and continuously updating models.
What Is Software Threat Modeling?
Threat modeling is the structured analysis of a system to identify potential security and privacy issues.
According to OWASP, a threat model is a structured representation of all information affecting an application’s security. It helps organizations understand threats and plan mitigations. The Threat Modeling Manifesto outlines four guiding questions:
-
What are we working on?
-
What can go wrong?
-
What are we going to do about it?
-
Did we do a good enough job?
While threat modeling applies to many domains, this webinar focused specifically on software application threat modeling.
Why You Need Threat Modeling Now
Increasing regulations, rising costs, and developer-to-security talent gaps make threat modeling essential.
Key drivers:
-
Security compliance: Standards like the U.S. EO 14028 and NIST SSDF now mandate threat modeling.
-
Developer empowerment: Developers outnumber security experts, so they need tools to build secure software.
-
Market competitiveness: Secure design accelerates delivery and reduces post-release security fixes.
| Challenge | Impact |
|---|---|
| Developer/Security Talent Gap | 1 security pro for every 122 developers |
| Regulatory Pressure | Threat modeling is required for compliance (e.g., EO 14028, NIST) |
| Speed vs. Security | Threat modeling helps deliver secure software faster |
7 Lessons for Effective Threat Modeling
Years of experience show that threat modeling must be objective-driven, actionable, and continuously improved.
1. Identify Clear Objectives
Don’t try to boil the ocean—scale threat modeling based on application risk.
Many organizations fail by applying the same heavy process to every app. Instead, tailor effort based on the risk profile. Define what you’re protecting and adjust the scope accordingly.
2. Move Beyond Diagrams
Diagrams are helpful, but not sufficient—focus on actionable outcomes.
Visuals can oversimplify or quickly become outdated. The goal is not just to draw data flows but to track mitigations and implement controls tied to real threats.
3. Make It Actionable for Developers
Developers must receive prescriptive, role-relevant guidance, not just a list of threats.
Since most developers aren’t security experts, threat models must translate into clear, contextual steps for remediation. Tools should align with their existing workflows.
4. Treat Threat Modeling as Continuous
Threat modeling must evolve with your architecture and release cycles.
It’s not a one-time activity. New components, third-party integrations, or threat vectors require ongoing updates. Automate tracking to maintain accuracy.
5. Automate to Scale
Manual threat modeling doesn’t scale—automation is key to reaching all apps.
As development speeds increase (DevOps, CI/CD), threat modeling must keep pace. Automation helps small security teams extend coverage across large application portfolios.
6. Be Prepared to Show Your Work
Auditable threat models are now critical for compliance and customer assurance.
Regulators and buyers want evidence of secure practices. Maintain detailed documentation of mitigations, decisions, and updates to prove security posture.
7. Free Isn’t Always Free
Free tools work for individuals, but fall short for enterprise-scale threat modeling.
While tools like the Microsoft Threat Modeling Tool are useful, they don’t provide automation, regulatory mapping, or support at scale. For growing programs, commercial solutions offer broader coverage and long-term efficiency.
| Tool Type | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Free Tools | Low-cost, accessible | Manual, hard to scale, limited support |
| Commercial Tools | Automation, compliance support, and scalable | Requires investment but offers strategic ROI |
Conclusion
Threat modeling succeeds when it’s continuous, developer-friendly, and automated to meet scale and regulatory demands.
Organizations should focus on:
-
Starting with risk-adjusted objectives
-
Supporting developers with prescriptive actions
-
Automating to scale across portfolios
-
Maintaining up-to-date, auditable models
These lessons from Security Compass’ work with clients help any organization build a sustainable, scalable threat modeling program.